维基百科:互助客栈/方针

维基百科,自由的百科全书
跳转至: 导航搜索

互助客棧消息发表 · 方针 · 技术发表 · 求助发表 · 条目探讨发表 · 其他发表 知识问答发表
快捷方式
WP:VPP
Nuvola apps edu miscellaneous.svg

本頁提出或讨论维基百科政策、方针,请参看方針與指引方针列表
繁简处理的议题请前往繁简处理讨论页
条目应当如何编辑才符合中立性原則寻求社群共识,请前往条目探讨留言。

請注重禮儀及尊重方針與指引,不要發表和本版無關的問題,留言后请务必签名(点击 Vector toolbar signature button.png )。立即發表新议题
發表前請先搜索存档,參考舊討論中的内容可節省您的時間。
存档图像
互助客栈(方针)档案馆
编辑

2003年 5月或之前 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2004年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2005年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2006年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2007年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2008年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2009年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2010年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2011年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
2012年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2013年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
2014年 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

公告板


WP:POINT[编辑]

該指引曾經提及,如果某個被提刪的條目未被刪除,編者就應該重新審視提刪的理由是否可取,而不是推薦被提刪的條目成為特色/優良條目。可悲的是,後一種情況恰恰是當前優良條目評選處出現的種種困境之一。上星期末,條目〈二十四節令鼓〉遭人提刪,某用戶為了挽留這篇條目,竟然推薦這篇條目成為優良條目(以達到目的),這個舉措實在是令人啼笑皆非。姑勿論此人動機為何,我認為他這樣做已經有破壞指引之嫌。這不只是我的想法,劉嘉君也是這樣認為的(如果我沒記錯)。大家認為我們要不要效仿刪除投票的方針那樣,為優良條目增加一條評選規矩,容許管理員(甚至其他取得「編輯」、「主編」資格的同工)即時關閉以擾亂維基百科為目的的優良條目評選?--春卷柯南夫子 ( ) 2014年11月9日 (日) 09:35 (UTC)

情況不同。--Kolyma留言) 2014年11月13日 (四) 14:02 (UTC)

提议删去WP:BOOK中的一句话[编辑]

"这表明本书至少有一定量的读者",是一个错误翻译。英文原文是with at least some of these works serving a general audience,原意是用以支持关注度的来源必须有一定的受众,否则即使有来源也仍然不合要求。这引起了那边许多争议,最终于2011年经讨论删除了这一限制。没想到在中文维基百科恰巧相反,以往有用户已"本书至少有一定量的读者"为由!vote保留。建议删除这一具歧义/争议的语句。--114.81.255.40留言) 2014年11月15日 (六) 12:08 (UTC)

个人观点,这句话不能成为理由。这不是保留理据,只是对标准的解读。翻译问题请相关编者介入。 @Rubyy T&S 2014年11月16日 (日) 03:59 (UTC)

Template:Orphan[编辑]

我在維護蘇利文原則頁面,需要在相關頁面加入內部連結,目前只有三個,我自己也覺得太少,所以想請問大概連結到什麼樣的程度可以移除這個模板。--—以上有簽名的留言由R96340討論)加入。 2014年11月20日 (四) 06:45 (UTC)

我覺得若有三個連至蘇利文原則的內部連結,蘇利文原則就不算是孤立條目了--Wolfch (留言)-基礎條目, 質量比較 2014年11月20日 (四) 16:06 (UTC)

How can edits complying with Wikipedia's rule be regarded as vandalism?[编辑]

  1. I concentrate on punctuation revision, what's the problem?
  2. I only concentrate on punctuation revision so I can do fast than usual without using automatic tools, what's the problem?
  3. Were my edit intervals really too short? I just submitted more than one articles at the same time after completing their revisions! Please review my edit history again! Or please tell me how many articles I can submit at the same time!
  4. User:Mewaqua criticizes my edit behavior is "只是依照既定「規則」刷編輯". I don't care my edit counts at all. If I cared, I should do much more than your imagine. How can a user arbitrarily judge another user?
  5. User:Mewaqua criticizes "有時胡亂刪掉參考文獻內新聞標題用作分隔句子的space"、"經常引致斜體字和數學公式不易閱讀"、"有時把本應分段的內容合併在一起", what are the evidences? Or how many errors in my over 9,000 edits? More than 0.5% or 1%? A few my edits might be wrong just as your edits might be incorrect. Why didn't you tell me what articles should be revised again or revise them directly by yourselves? How many Chinese Wikipedians are so unfriendly?
  6. User:578985s just doubted I am a robot or using a robot, then reported to vandalism. Administrator User:Kuailong also agreed to him. In English Wikipedia, they say "The edits of the reported user must be obvious vandalism or obvious spam." Why is Chinese Wikipedia so arbitrary and unfriendly?
  7. Some users appreciated my edits. How can Administrator ignore this fact intentionally?
  8. If my edits is correct without error, what's the problem? Or what's bad to Wikipedia? Why can some users always revert my edits just because they don't like their articles to be touched? See:
  1. IMI TAR-21突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  2. 雷明登887霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  3. 伯奈利M1 Super 90霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  4. 伯奈利新星霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  5. 伯奈利拉斐爾CrioComfort霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  6. 伯奈利拉斐爾霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  7. 齊亞帕犀牛式左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  8. 伯奈利達文西霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  9. VHS突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  10. PP-19野牛冲锋枪 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  11. HS2000手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  12. 瓦爾特PPQ手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  13. CZ蠍式EVO 3 A1衝鋒槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  14. 貝瑞塔Mx4 Storm衝鋒槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  15. 維涅龍衝鋒槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  16. HP9-1霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  17. 白朗寧大威力手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  18. 柯爾特滑軌手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  19. 金柏特裝型手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  20. 白朗寧雙動手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  21. 64式微声冲锋枪 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  22. MP-445瓦良格手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  23. DSR-1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  24. LSAT輕機槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  25. 歐瑞康KBA機炮 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  26. IWI X95突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  27. B&T APR狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  28. 格洛克20 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  29. 雷明登1911 R1手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  30. 格洛克29 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  31. 春田M1A半自動步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  32. 貝瑞塔ARX-160突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  33. 伯奈利超級達文西霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  34. 伯奈利超級新星霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  35. 伯奈利M2 Super 90霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  36. 弗蘭基SPAS-12霰彈槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  37. SIG MPX衝鋒槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  38. 貝瑞塔Pico手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  39. SVU狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  40. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  41. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  42. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  43. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  44. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  45. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  46. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  47. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  48. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  49. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  50. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  51. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  52. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  53. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  54. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  55. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  56. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  57. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  58. 瓦爾特PP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  59. MG3通用機槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  60. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  61. 瓦爾特P5手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  62. HK MSG90狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  63. HK G3SG/1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  64. OTs-14突击步枪 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  65. HK PSG1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  66. 56式自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  67. M1911手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  68. SA80突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  69. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  70. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  71. FN FNC突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  72. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  73. 斯泰爾斥候步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  74. 儒格MK II手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  75. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Alfredo ougaowen.
  76. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  77. M1879帝國左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  78. FN FNC突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  79. SKS半自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  80. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  81. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  82. MG3通用機槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  83. 斯泰爾斥候步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  84. HK PSG1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  85. HK MSG90狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  86. 瓦爾特PP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  87. M1911手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  88. 56式自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  89. SA80突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  90. OTs-14突击步枪 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  91. HK G3SG/1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  92. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  93. 瓦爾特P5手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  94. 博查特C-93手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  95. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  96. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  97. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  98. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  99. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  100. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  101. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  102. 瓦爾特P5手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  103. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  104. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  105. 博查特C-93手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  106. HK G3SG/1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  107. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  108. 56式自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  109. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  110. 斯泰爾斥候步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  111. M1911手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  112. MG3通用機槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  113. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  114. SA80突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  115. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  116. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  117. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  118. HK USP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  119. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  120. SVU狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  121. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  122. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  123. HK PSG1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  124. SR-25狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  125. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  126. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  127. SA80突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  128. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  129. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  130. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  131. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  132. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  133. FN Five-seveN手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  134. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  135. HK PSG1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  136. SA80突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  137. SIG P226手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  138. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  139. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  140. SVU狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  141. FN Five-seveN手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  142. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  143. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  144. 希普諾夫2A42機炮 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  145. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  146. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  147. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  148. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  149. M16突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  150. HK MSG90狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  151. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  152. HK416突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  153. FX-05突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  154. HK PSG1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  155. HK G3SG/1狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  156. FN FNC突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  157. 56式自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  158. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  159. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  160. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  161. 博查特C-93手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  162. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  163. 希普諾夫2A42機炮 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  164. 史密斯威森3號左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  165. M1911手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  166. M16突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  167. 斯泰爾AUG突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  168. M1879帝國左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  169. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  170. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  171. HK USP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  172. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  173. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  174. HK USP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  175. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  176. 瓦爾特PP手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  177. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  178. 納甘M1895左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  179. 瓦爾特P38手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  180. 柯爾特單動式陸軍左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  181. M1879帝國左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  182. 恩菲爾德左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  183. 史密斯威森3號左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  184. 斯泰爾AUG突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  185. 博查特C-93手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  186. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  187. 史密斯威森西格瑪半自動手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  188. 希普諾夫2A42機炮 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  189. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  190. HK P9S手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  191. 十年式擲彈筒 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  192. User talk:Time killer has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  193. FN P90衝鋒槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  194. M16突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  195. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  196. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  197. 斯泰爾AUG突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  198. 柯爾特單動式陸軍左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  199. HK G3自動步槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  200. M1879帝國左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  201. 柯爾特騎兵型左輪手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  202. 希普諾夫2A42機炮 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  203. 史密斯威森西格瑪半自動手槍 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  204. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:ArikamaI.
  205. M16突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  206. 貝瑞塔92手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  207. FN Five-seveN手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  208. 瓦爾特P38手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  209. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  210. PSO-1光學瞄準鏡 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  211. 斯泰爾AUG突擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  212. 貝瑞塔93R手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  213. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  214. SVU狙擊步槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  215. 史密斯威森西格瑪半自動手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  216. 博查特C-93手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
  217. 魯格手槍 has been reverted by User:Krasnyy Suou.
and more...

--tk 2014年11月23日 (日) 03:15 (UTC)